Raise your hand if you've blown up an N54!

Have you blown up an N54?

  • Yes

    Votes: 52 42.3%
  • No

    Votes: 71 57.7%

  • Total voters
    123

matreyia

Major
Apr 19, 2017
1,780
711
0
Ride
335i e93
No they wont. you can quote any internet article you want. I site real world experience.

Hey Tony, it seems to me that you get more bang for your buck if you upgrade to forged pistons, sings, connecting rods and it's not really crucial to get a closed deck if you are aiming only for 700whp? Or am I wrong?
 

langsbr

Captain
Apr 5, 2017
1,274
776
0
Ride
07 335i 6MT e90
Having looked specifically for examples of it, it's all I see now...plenty of threads on N54Tech, Facebook N54 pages and a handful of YouTube videos.

I think this is possibly a case of confirmation bias. Kind of like when you get a new car, you start seeing every example of that car. There are things that are absolutely terrible and common on N54s - MSD80 mosfets, injectors, even waterpumps, etc. Bearings are not typical, but you will definitely find the case here and there. It is an engine after all, and the e90 3 series was one of the highest selling BMWs ever, so you're bound to find examples. A think spun hubs are more common than spun bearings, but very few people have spun the crank hub. It just gets talked about more since it happens at high power levels and there is very little or affordable that can be done about it.
 

fmorelli

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Aug 11, 2017
3,763
3,618
0
58
Virginia
Ride
E89 Z4 35i, F10 535d
I also see a lot of people bragging about their $4,500 cars which they are beating the ever-living out of. Maintenance matters more than anything. And that includes, the awareness of having an issue and needing maintenance.

A friend recently bought an inexpensive E90 (twice the above price, though) with over 100k miles. Lots of maintenance. When I took a few things apart, plenty of oil and dirt in the engine compartment, lots of missing hardware (like holding down the cowl assembly), JB Weld holding together the upper radiator snout, extra parts in the top shock tower perch, et cetera. And it had maintenance records. When a car gets to be 10+ years old, and has performance, it can often have 3-4 owners. One becomes an automotive archeologist. For whatever maintenance it may have, lots of hands have often touched it by 100+k. Of course there are cream puffs, but nonetheless I think my experience with this particular E90 is hardly uncommon.

Filippo
 

Rob09msport

Major
Oct 28, 2017
1,929
664
0
Monroe CT
Ride
09 335i msport le mans 18 x5
I also see a lot of people bragging about their $4,500 cars which they are beating the ever-living out of. Maintenance matters more than anything. And that includes, the awareness of having an issue and needing maintenance.

A friend recently bought an inexpensive E90 (twice the above price, though) with over 100k miles. Lots of maintenance. When I took a few things apart, plenty of oil and dirt in the engine compartment, lots of missing hardware (like holding down the cowl assembly), JB Weld holding together the upper radiator snout, extra parts in the top shock tower perch, et cetera. And it had maintenance records. When a car gets to be 10+ years old, and has performance, it can often have 3-4 owners. One becomes an automotive archeologist. For whatever maintenance it may have, lots of hands have often touched it by 100+k. Of course there are cream puffs, but nonetheless I think my experience with this particular E90 is hardly uncommon.

Filippo
That's why with me I'd rather buy I higher mileage single owner car then lower mileage multiple. Especially cause usually if car has seen alot of owners it may be a lemon and if you ask everyone will just blame previous owners for any issues
 

fmorelli

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Aug 11, 2017
3,763
3,618
0
58
Virginia
Ride
E89 Z4 35i, F10 535d
Not to digress, @Rob09msport, but yeah ... the reasoning is ... whatever is easiest to discern lineage-wise. The more I know about a car the better. The older it is, the harder that generally gets. A three owner car with records is better than a 1-owner car with no records. A specialty car in some ways is easier to buy - the N54 cars are all pedestrian rides. As they get older, many become cheap-ass sport sedans for people without money / car knowledge / take-your-pick.

My Z4 will be a bargain for someone, one day. It has sat most of its life with me apart. I've only clocked 7k miles in the last 3 years (aaaaargh).

Filippo
 

gorspeed

Specialist
Nov 5, 2016
76
27
0
Columbus
Not to digress, @Rob09msport,
My Z4 will be a bargain for someone, one day. It has sat most of its life with me apart. I've only clocked 7k miles in the last 3 years (aaaaargh).

Filippo


I seriously thought I was the only one. I hit around 700 to 1k miles a year in a good year. the last 2 years probably 1300 miles total.
 

The Banshee

Corporal
Nov 18, 2017
175
104
0
Lehigh Valley PA
Ride
2008 335xi coupe 6466 MT
Hey Tony, it seems to me that you get more bang for your buck if you upgrade to forged pistons, sings, connecting rods and it's not really crucial to get a closed deck if you are aiming only for 700whp? Or am I wrong?

I am thinking the same thing. Forged pistons and upgraded rods seem to be crucial. Would be nice to avoid the inserts or the cost of sleeves if not going above 700. 700 and below seems to be a nice place for most of us for many reasons.
 

fmorelli

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Aug 11, 2017
3,763
3,618
0
58
Virginia
Ride
E89 Z4 35i, F10 535d
I seriously thought I was the only one. I hit around 700 to 1k miles a year in a good year. the last 2 years probably 1300 miles total.
Honestly half the time has been my project work, but the other half has been 3rd party products that have failures, and trying to deal with that.

Filippo
 

kayzrx82

Corporal
Apr 4, 2018
110
88
0
Ride
n54 335i
The whole H beam vs I beam rod debates is biased. You have to take into account rod weight, material grade, RPM Range and cross section. Too many variable at play to say one is better than the other.
 

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
The whole H beam vs I beam rod debates is biased. You have to take into account rod weight, material grade, RPM Range and cross section. Too many variable at play to say one is better than the other.
While that's true when looking at specific rods as examples, that's not correct when fundamentally looking at the design.
 

matreyia

Major
Apr 19, 2017
1,780
711
0
Ride
335i e93
I am thinking the same thing. Forged pistons and upgraded rods seem to be crucial. Would be nice to avoid the inserts or the cost of sleeves if not going above 700. 700 and below seems to be a nice place for most of us for many reasons.

Here's the thing... close decks eliminate the open spaces the the stock coolant flows through. So you in theory have more heat, more knock...the question is - is that a worth while trade off? Vs. Just jeeping open deck and upgrading piston, rings, rods and all bearings?
 
Last edited:

MoreBoost

Sergeant
Jul 27, 2017
361
143
0
Ride
335i
Here's the thing... close decks eliminate the open spaces tht the stock coolant flows through. So you in theory have more heat, more knock...the question is - is that a worth qhile trade off? Vs. Just jeeping open deck and upgrading piston, rings, rods and all bearings?

I don't know too much about engines but I'd be worried about the cylinders ovaling over time and losing compression.
Also the head lifting off. So sleeves and head studs would be on my list.
 
Jan 31, 2017
377
760
0
www.hydraperformance.com
Ride
2010 135i 6MT
Here's the thing... close decks eliminate the open spaces tht the stock coolant flows through. So you in theory have more heat, more knock...the question is - is that a worth qhile trade off? Vs. Just jeeping open deck and upgrading piston, rings, rods and all bearings?

FWIW 4B11 blocks are open deck, yet can be made to handle >250whp per cyl when built right and sleeved. By comparison, the most powerful N54 out there is yet to crack 160whp/cyl...
 

matreyia

Major
Apr 19, 2017
1,780
711
0
Ride
335i e93
FWIW 4B11 blocks are open deck, yet can be made to handle >250whp per cyl when built right and sleeved. By comparison, the most powerful N54 out there is yet to crack 160whp/cyl...


So no need to sleeve or close deck if under 960 whp?
 

matreyia

Major
Apr 19, 2017
1,780
711
0
Ride
335i e93
I don't know too much about engines but I'd be worried about the cylinders ovaling over time and losing compression.
Also the head lifting off. So sleeves and head studs would be on my list.

Forgot about the head studs. Sleeves reinforce the cylinder walls without closing deck? Seems like a no brainer then?
 

fmorelli

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Aug 11, 2017
3,763
3,618
0
58
Virginia
Ride
E89 Z4 35i, F10 535d
So no need to sleeve or close deck if under 960 whp?
I would word the question differently. Or I just think this question makes zero sense.

Back in the real world, failures often happen when everything doesn't work 110% right. It's a grey line. So design approach deals with the myriad of variances - material composition deviations, design deviations, assembly deviations, and the 1,000's of different real-world environment variances that make things not work like textbook fantasy land.

A built motor is just as much an exercise in insurance against everything that one can think of which can go off script (and all the stuff one can't think of) as it is trying to hit a magic number like 960whp.

Filippo
 

matreyia

Major
Apr 19, 2017
1,780
711
0
Ride
335i e93
I would word the question differently. Or I just think this question makes zero sense.

Back in the real world, failures often happen when everything doesn't work 110% right. It's a grey line. So design approach deals with the myriad of variances - material composition deviations, design deviations, assembly deviations, and the 1,000's of different real-world environment variances that make things not work like textbook fantasy land.

A built motor is just as much an exercise in insurance against everything that one can think of which can go off script (and all the stuff one can't think of) as it is trying to hit a magic number like 960whp.

Filippo
That 960 values is based on 160 per cylinder as stated by the comment previous. Nothing to do with what I plan. Insurance for my power levels would be pistons, ring, rods, bearings without closed deck or sleeves. Because I only want 700 max and realistically 650... nowhere near 960 at all.